The best argument against e-mail based…
The best argument against e-mail based authentication is that it's impossible to guarantee the delivery of e-mails. Once a user says they've checked spam, there's basically nothing else you can do for them beyond checking your configuration for the millionth time.
Then you're in luck, because you'll pay $0 for my 2¢ when you subscribe to my work, whether via RSS or your favorite social network.
I also have a monthly newsletter where I write high-tempo, thought-provoking essays about life, in case that's more your speed:
And if you'd rather give your eyes a rest and your ears a workout, might I suggest my long-form solo podcast, Breaking Change? Odd are, you haven't heard anything quite like it.